Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. · Dom works in the car business
1-on-1 calls by appointmentFree ToolsContact

Negotiate the out-the-door price, not the payment

Why the out-the-door number is the only fair way to compare offers, and a simple script to get it in writing.

5 min read · Updated 2026-10-27 · By Dom

TL;DR

  • Ask every dealer for a written out-the-door (OTD) price on the same VIN or trim.
  • Keep trade-in, financing, and add-ons as separate conversations.
  • A monthly payment can be lowered by stretching the term; OTD can't be faked.
  • Use the OTD calculator to check any quote's math.

Free calculators for this: Negotiation script generator · Dealer add-on checker · Out-the-door price calculator · Buyer's order explainer

Why OTD

The OTD price is everything you pay to drive away: price, dealer fees, tax, title, and registration, minus rebates. Two dealers can quote the same payment with very different totals, because the term, down payment, or products differ. OTD removes those levers.

A simple script

"Hi, I'm shopping [year, model, trim, color]. I'm ready to buy this week. Could you email me your out-the-door price, itemized, for stock number [#]? I'll handle financing and trade-in separately."

Deal Assessment · Start here

Got an out-the-door quote? Check every line.

Deal Assessment · One Quote gives a Deal Assessment of your quote: tax for your state and county, the doc fee against your state's rules, add-ons flagged as optional or not, and a script for what to say. $69 one-time, results in minutes.

Get my Deal Assessment · $69See an example Deal Assessment

Compare offers

  1. Put each quote into the OTD calculator with your state selected.
  2. Check that tax was charged on the right base. For example, California doesn't deduct trade-ins and Michigan caps the trade-in credit at $12,000 in 2026.
  3. Question any add-on you didn't ask for.

Market context

In September 2026, Kelley Blue Book put the average new-vehicle transaction price at $50,562 with incentives averaging 6.6% of the price, about $3,359. Discounts vary a lot by brand and how much inventory a dealer has, so ask.

Deal Assessment · Start here

Have a dealer quote?

Get a Deal Assessment of your real quote, with what's fair, what's optional, and what to say. $69 one-time.

Get my Deal Assessment · $69See an example Deal Assessment

AI Desk · For the whole search

Still shopping?

Ask questions as they come up, compare offers and leases, look up recalls by VIN, and get 2 Deal Assessments a month. $89/month, cancel anytime.

See the AI Desk · $89/monthRenews monthly until you cancel. Cancel anytime.

Sources

  1. Kelley Blue Book / Cox Automotive, September 2026 ATP report
  2. Michigan Form 485 (2026 trade-in cap)

Checked 2026-10-27. Laws, rates, and programs change. Confirm before you rely on them. General information, not financial, legal, or tax advice.