TL;DR
- The lender approves a 'buy rate.' The dealer may offer you a higher 'contract rate' and keep part of the difference.
- Get a pre-approval from your bank or credit union first. It's your benchmark.
- Ask: 'Is this the best rate you were approved for?' and compare APRs, not payments.
- Each extra point on a $35,000, 72-month loan costs roughly $17 a month (about $1,200 total).
Free calculators for this: Dealer vs. bank rate calculator · Negotiation script generator · Auto loan refinance calculator · Car payment calculator
What happens after you fill out the credit app
When you finance at a dealership, you usually aren't borrowing from the dealer. The finance office sends your application to several lenders: banks, credit unions, and the automaker's own finance company (the "captive"). Each lender that approves you sends back terms, including a buy rate, the lowest rate that lender will accept for your credit profile.
The dealer then offers you a contract rate. It can equal the buy rate, or it can be higher. When it's higher, the lender typically shares part of that extra interest with the dealer as compensation. This is called dealer reserve or markup, and it's legal. More detail: dealer finance reserve, explained. Lenders' agreements with dealers usually limit how much can be added.
Why it matters
Rate differences add up. Using this site's payment calculator: $35,000 financed for 72 months is about $595/month at 6.9% APR and about $612/month at 7.9% APR. That one point is about $17 a month, or roughly $1,200 over the loan. These are illustrations; your rate depends on your credit and the lender.
How to protect yourself
- Get pre-approved before you shop. A credit union or bank approval gives you a real number to beat. Multiple auto-loan inquiries in a short window are generally treated as one for scoring purposes. Step by step: get pre-approved before the dealership.
- Negotiate the price first, financing second. Settle the out-the-door price, then talk rate.
- Compare APR and total cost, not the payment. A lower payment can come from a longer term.
- Ask directly: "Is this the best rate you were approved for, and which lender is it?" If they beat your pre-approval, great. If not, use yours.
- Read the retail installment contract. The Truth in Lending box shows the APR, finance charge, amount financed, and total of payments. Make sure they match what you agreed to.
Deal Assessment · Start here
Is your rate marked up? A Deal Assessment solves the real APR.
Enter the amount financed, payment and term from your quote. Deal Assessment · One Quote solves the APR the payment really implies, compares it with the average for your credit tier, and flags a likely markup. $69 one-time.
Promotional rates
Automaker "special APR" offers (like 0.9% or 1.9%) come through the captive lender, usually for top credit tiers and specific models and terms. They often can't be combined with cash rebates. See rebate vs. low APR or the quick answer 0% APR vs. a cash rebate to compare.
Average rates right now
In Q2 2026, Experian reported average rates of 6.35% for new-car loans and 11.19% for used, with big differences by credit tier. See credit tiers and your rate, the quick answer dealer financing vs. a bank or credit union, and for used cars, used-car financing: rates, terms, and traps.
Deal Assessment · Start here
Have a dealer quote?
Get a Deal Assessment of your real quote, with what's fair, what's optional, and what to say. $69 one-time.
AI Desk · For the whole search
Still shopping?
Ask questions as they come up, compare offers and leases, look up recalls by VIN, and get 2 Deal Assessments a month. $89/month, cancel anytime.
See the AI Desk · $89/monthRenews monthly until you cancel. Cancel anytime.
Go deeper (members guides)
- Dealer finance reserve: how a dealer-arranged rate can end up higher than the buy rate
- How much should you put down on a car? Enough to start right-side up
- Credit tiers and your rate (Q2 2026 data)
- Get pre-approved before the dealership (then let them beat it)
Included with any paid service: a Deal Assessment (library for 90 days) or an AI Desk plan (while subscribed). See pricing.
Sources
- Experian, Auto Loan Rates and Financing (Q2 2026 data)
- CFPB, What is a buy rate / dealer markup? (consumer answers)
Checked 2026-10-27. Laws, rates, and programs change. Confirm before you rely on them. General information, not financial, legal, or tax advice.